Homeowners have many options when it comes time to choose a shingle manufacturer. Some of the most popular ones include Malarkey and GAF. What is the difference between them? Take a look at our comparison of these two brands.
Malarkey Pros and Cons
Malarkey shingles have received high marks from homeowners. This shingle manufacturer produces high-quality and premium products. However, they can be more expensive than a traditional asphalt brand like GAF.
In popularity, GAF has better name recognition in the industry. That doesn’t mean that Malarkey is a poor brand. It is just one of those hidden gems in the shingle market. Like most manufacturers, Malarkey has several types of shingles. The Windsor Scotchgard is one of the company’s designer shingles. They have the appearance of a traditional cedar shake, with the patented durable NEX asphalt and Scotchgard to protect the shingle.
After that, Malarkey offers a laminated architectural shingle. Several lines of these shingles include the Legacy, Vista, Ecoasis, and Highlander. The Legacy also features NEX and Scotchgard protection. Vista comes in an option that offers algae and stain resistance. The Ecoasis features solar reflective granules that look like standard shingles. The Highlander shingles come with NEX asphalt and optional algae protection.
Finally, Malarkey does produce three-tab shingles. You can find the Dura-Seal line with sustainable NEX asphalt and staining protection in this range.
Malarkey does have some of the best warranties in the industry. The warranty covers protection with 100% coverage before the materials are prorated. Malarkey refers to this time before the proration as the “Right Start” period, providing you with the best-extended warranty in the market. Like many other brands, homeowners can only transfer the Malarkey shingle warranty once.
Now take a look at the disadvantages of these Malarkey shingles.
While Malarkey does have a great warranty, the one-time transfer is a drawback for many homeowners. If the warranty is transferred after the Right Start period, it will default to only two years. Malarkey does not have a wide range of color and shingle options compared to other manufacturers.
You will want to find an experienced contractor with these types of shingles. While Malarkey rarely has issues with the manufacturing process, an inexperienced person can cause damage if they do not install them correctly on your roof. Malarkey does offer programs to install its product, including the Malarkey Certified Residential Contractor and Malarkey Emerald Contractor certifications.
GAF Pros and Cons
If you want a well-known company, then GAF could be your best choice. Many contractors and homeowners trust this brand for their shingling needs. GAF has many options that can suit any type of budget. These shingles are affordable, but they offer top-of-the-line products as well. GAF’s Stainguard technology protects shingles against staining and algae growth.
Timberline is GAF’s most popular product in the market. In fact, it is the most used shingle in the United States. These shingles are a good choice for anyone who wants a high-quality shingle with plenty of color options.
GAF does have designer shingles. As you may have imagined, these shingles have a higher cost. The Stateline and Camelot II are luxury shingles that can come in custom colors. If you want something more architecturally pleasing, then make sure to choose these products.
Finally, the Royal Sovereign three-tab shingle was designed with durability and affordability in mind. They are an excellent option for those who want an affordable asphalt shingle that will withstand the elements and harsh weather. Along with that, these shingles are available in several colors to match most home exteriors.
Like Malarkey, GAF does have excellent warranties. All GAF shingles will have a lifetime limited warranty. Also, there are five comprehensive warranties, including the exclusive Golden Pledge Limited Warranty with a 25-year workmanship coverage. Plus, most of these warranties are transferable.
In the GAF vs Malarkey debate, you need to consider the cons of these shingles. GAF products can have issues over the years. Some contractors have seen problems with granule loss. Granule loss is typical. When it happens to GAF shingles, they can become defective. Warranties can be voided if the contractors don’t follow the company’s specific manufacturing rules. Along with that, some exclusions can occur with an enhanced warranty. GAF shingles are popular but can get expensive as you upgrade the product line.
Malarkey vs GAF: Which One To Choose?
Both homeowners and contractors highly rate both shingles. GAF is the most popular option, meaning you can easily find them. A professional roofer can only order Malarkey shingle products. This company also has a limited product line. However, the shingles are backed by the best warranties on the market. GAF carries an extensive product warranty, but the contractor must follow specific regulations to ensure continuous coverage. If you want a wide range of colors and styles, GAF is the best line for you.
Find a Reputable Roofing Company
If you still cannot choose between GAF and Malarkey, reach out to RGB Construction. Our roofing team can help you select the right shingle manufacturer for your needs. These two companies offer excellent products for your roof. We will take the time to find the best option for your home. Plus, our roofing team will ensure a professional installation of all these products. When it comes time to add new shingles to your roof, you can count on us. Schedule your consultation by calling 856-264-9093.